Posted By Jeff Sichta on 15 Feb 2011 09:43 PM
Ironically, Victor Milan has expressed similar feelings about the last two "Guardians" books, which he did not write...
Yeah...but the primary difference is that Milan didn't create the Guardians series.
For the record, referring to another post you made...I don't recall that the author of or the Guardians series itself was "universally reveiled" in the OL forums.
What OL fans didn't care for--which is reflected in the reviews--is Milan's careless, thoughtless and often arrogant rewrites of established OL characters and continuity in order to accomodate the thinly-disguised versions of the Guardians.
His work on the Guardians series wasn't criticized as far as I recollect.
Funny-- it was recently brought to my attention that a couple of posts were made on the Graphic Audio forums where I was criticized for my handling of the Team Phoenix demise in
Dark Goddess.
Apparently Milan had written out his TP/Guardians characters in his last OL contribution, but that manuscript wasn't brought to my attention by the OL editor by the time I turned in
Dark Goddess.
It probably wouldn't have made much difference even if I had known it.
And just guessing...maybe the OL editor found the TP demise scene too damn entertaining to have it either excised or altered.