I wished I felt as enthusiastic as Grantbo about this lastest DL fare.
I just finished it last night, and had to let it sink in. I think this may be one of the hardest DL I could rate.
First off, hats off to Rik Hoskin for writing one of the most seriously written sci-fi stories in this series. The concepts were great, but at times, went a little overboard for me. And I read TONS of sci-fi!
This is far far way better than Rik's other 2 DL books. He seems to have done his homework, having actually read the original author's early books, because this book mentions and has numerous things that point out to that fact.
Again, major kudos go out to Rik for that.
Although Chrono Spasm is by no means a bad book, I still found a lot of little problems as I read the book.
Like I mentioned in my earlier post of the first 50 pages, the book started very strong and exciting, even kinda giving me the feeling of the older style Laurence James prose. And I suppose having the companions jumping back into Alaska again had a lot to do with this. Again, Hoskin did a pretty superb job at this here. Much better than a lot of past and current authors.
But this book was chock-full of editorial mistakes. If the editor could have caught what I did, and sent the manuscript back for a slight rewrite here and there, this could have been one of the best all-time classic DL's ever.
Some things that were not caught by the editor: 1: Endless supply of ammo. So many times in the action sequences, whether they had a mere six-shooter or an automatic, endless bullets came out of them. Like a Hollywood movie, there was almost no mention of reloading or even how they could possibly carrying that much ordnance in a captivity situation.
2: The captors had been taking and handling slaves for a seemingly long time, but yet they ignore the fact that Doc is carrying a potential weapon in his cane...? No, no, no...there was no need of such an oversight. These guys were too good to let this happen. This is where Ryan's scarf could have came into play, but it was never mentioned until page 200-and-something I noticed.
3: Why do most authors ignore the fact that Mildred and J. B. are an item? This particular book had the companions in some of the worst captivity they have come across since probably Philipson's awesome Xilbaba duology, and there were scenes where J.B. and Mildred had some action alone time, being away from the rest of the group, and not once did they act intimate, talk intimate, and this the author could have drawn out some great dramatic effect, instead of using way too many cute jokes and sayings, that only undermined the dire straits they were in. Many times that kinda threw me out of the story, making me think the companions feel they were not in THAT much danger.
Now, the bitter cold weather: I loved the author's description and usage of this! I can't recall the last DL book where they have been in bitter, bad weather. Too many perfect weather books in recent years. I hope future books bring it back to unpredictable weather patterns like the older books. I personally don't want a healing Earth in my DL. I read them for the pure escapism for a genre I love. And I want my DL and its world to be NUKED! This book provided that in spades. Again, major kudos to this author in that regard.
But on the other side of the coin, Hoskin made the weather soo bad, that the companions did too much with no food or hot sub-coffee to keep them going. Especially Ryan and Doc. The women got food, but the author never mentioned Ryan and Doc, or Jak and Ricky, ever getting any substance. They were all under-dressed, too. They battled extreme weather much too long with nothing to sustain them. If the editor could have had the author pen some here here and there, with a couple of fires to keep them somewhat warm, this could have come off as that much more believable. Hey, I know this is sci-fi, but utilizing as much realism in basic survival and combat tactics just makes it come off as that much more believable, thus more exciting.
Now, with all that being written, the good is that an author has FINALLY used one and fresh aspect of the Big Elephant in the Room that could be used for countless and fresh storylines - Operation Chronos! Thank you sir!